The Polar Transition from Alpha to Beta Regions Set by a Surface Buoyancy Flux Inversion


Review this paper

Submitted by rcaneill

Oct. 24, 2023, 6:57 a.m.

The Polar Transition from Alpha to Beta Regions Set by a Surface Buoyancy Flux Inversion

Romain Caneill Fabien Roquet Gurvan Madec Jonas Nycander
R. Caneill, F. Roquet, G. Madec, and J. Nycander, “The Polar Transition from Alpha to Beta Regions Set by a Surface Buoyancy Flux Inversion,” Journal of Physical Oceanography, vol. 52, no. 8, pp. 1887–1902, Aug. 2022. [Online]. Available: https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/phoc/52/8/JPO-D-21-0295.1.xml
DOI:  10.1175/JPO-D-21-0295.1          


  Mean reproducibility score:   0.0/10   |   Number of reviews:   1

Brief Description
Using an ocean numerical model, we studied how the polar transition zone is impacted by surface buoyancy fluxes and the equation of state for seawater.
The reproducibility is made through the snakemake workflow (Python). Output of the model runs are available on zenodo for only rerunning analyses. However, the runs themselves are also reproducible with the help of snakemake (slightly harder as the model runs need to be conducted on HPC).
Why should we reproduce your paper?
I tried hard to make it reproducible, so hopefully this paper can serve as an example on how reproducibility can be achieved. I think that being reproducible with only few commands to type in a terminal is quite an achievment. At least in my field, where I usually see code published along with paper, but with almost no documentation on how to rerun it.
What should reviewers focus on?
One of the hardest point for reproducibility is getting the proper environment with all installed packages. This can be the tricky part, and this may be where the analyses become non-reproducible, unfortunately. However, I think that with a little effort, it is possible to fix the potential environment issues.

Resources


Associated event