We reproduced the manuscript with R version 4.0.3 and 4.0.5 (2021-03-31) and R studio Version 1.4.1106 (Windows 10)
We were 3 people with various levels of familiarity of Rmarkdown.
None
We reproduced the manuscript with R version 4.0.3 and 4.0.5 (2021-03-31) and R studio Version 1.4.1106 (Windows 10)
It would be nice to have an overview in the README file about the descriptions and organisation of the subfolders, for example, where manuscript.Rmd is located. It was a bit difficult to find the main file(manuscript.rmd) but once we did it was easy to go ahead.
Could consider a solution like renv to “freeze” dependency versions, as failures are more likely to happen as time goes and dependencies are further developed.
Nicely organized with a specific function for each manuscript figure! We also liked the info about compilation versions at the end of the manuscript!
Include info about the structure of the folders and what each one includes so that it is easier to navigate.
Each file included enough details about the content.
There were three of us doing this review: Yuliya Leontyeva, Robert Karlsson, Betty Syriopoulou Thank you for sharing the material, in general it has been a very nice experiment and the package was well made. :) Really loved the background story! The idea of creating an article in the form of a package can be a template for other reproducible articles, especially for R users.